{
  "schema": "otterchip.model_x.e_constraints_audit/1",
  "date": "2026-11-06",
  "kind": "Audit of repository evidence; no new human-factors or product certification",
  "answer": "Yes. Model E was a compact, fixed-component, fixed-body compromise, not an unconstrained ergonomic optimum. Height and tilt were varied, and neither selected value hit the search bound. Setback hit the 250 mm bound in the numerically best sampled design; published E instead used 180 mm for compactness.",
  "e_selection": {
    "published": {
      "heightMm": 245,
      "tiltDeg": 18,
      "setbackMm": 180,
      "deckMm": 62.5,
      "slopeDeg": 0,
      "bodyDepthMm": 415.4,
      "J": 0.014797756266410417
    },
    "best_sampled": {
      "params": {
        "slope": 2,
        "midioverlap": 42,
        "deckAdd": 0,
        "padgap": 20,
        "padrise": 6,
        "mididrop": 23,
        "deck": 65.5,
        "height": 225,
        "tilt": 18,
        "setback": 250
      },
      "J": 0.009197367531855518,
      "depthMmRear92": 482.059,
      "note": "best SAMPLED within bounds (setback at 250 bound; slope 2, underlap 42 near the black-key exposure limit 23.1 vs 23). Not a global or unconstrained optimum; solver hip-grid discontinuities make sub-mm optimisation meaningless.",
      "loss_reduction_vs_published_E_percent": 37.84620204393608
    },
    "interpretation": "The approximately 38% reduction is in the same designer-heuristic loss, not 38% better human ergonomics. E captures 87% of the best sampled improvement over M at about 67 mm less depth.",
    "selection_source": "hardware/otterchip_model_e/optimization/native-review-notes.txt:16",
    "results_source": "hardware/otterchip_model_e/optimization/scripts/build-results.cjs:106"
  },
  "search_bounds": [
    {
      "parameter": "screen center height",
      "range": [
        190,
        300
      ],
      "unit": "mm",
      "fine_step": 5,
      "selected": 245,
      "best_sampled": 225,
      "binding": false
    },
    {
      "parameter": "screen tilt back from vertical",
      "range": [
        5,
        35
      ],
      "unit": "degrees",
      "fine_step": 1,
      "selected": 18,
      "best_sampled": 18,
      "binding": false
    },
    {
      "parameter": "screen setback behind typing-key center",
      "range": [
        130,
        250
      ],
      "unit": "mm",
      "fine_step": 5,
      "selected": 180,
      "best_sampled": 250,
      "binding": true
    },
    {
      "parameter": "deck slope",
      "values": [
        0,
        1,
        2,
        3,
        4
      ],
      "unit": "degrees",
      "selected": 0,
      "best_sampled": 2,
      "comment": "Negative slope not studied; physical gate allows 0 to 10, but search only sampled 0 to 4."
    },
    {
      "parameter": "MIDI underlap",
      "values": [
        25,
        30,
        35,
        39,
        42
      ],
      "unit": "mm",
      "selected": 39,
      "best_sampled": 42,
      "comment": "42 mm nearly binds black-key exposure:23.1 mm vs23 mm minimum."
    },
    {
      "parameter": "deck height above normalized physical floor",
      "values": [
        0,
        1,
        2.5,
        5,
        10
      ],
      "unit": "mm",
      "selected": 0,
      "best_sampled": 0
    },
    {
      "parameter": "pad gap",
      "values": [
        6,
        10,
        14.5,
        20
      ],
      "unit": "mm",
      "selected": 10,
      "best_sampled": 20,
      "comment": "Normalization additionally clamps the gap to the available space."
    },
    {
      "parameter": "pad rise",
      "values": [
        6,
        7,
        8.5,
        11
      ],
      "unit": "mm",
      "selected": 7,
      "best_sampled": 6
    }
  ],
  "search_method": {
    "stage1_body_configs": 2000,
    "stage1_ages": [
      3,
      6,
      9,
      12
    ],
    "stage2_body_configs": 25,
    "stage2_ages": [
      3,
      4,
      5,
      6,
      7,
      8,
      9,
      10,
      11,
      12
    ],
    "stature_factors": [
      1,
      0.92,
      1.08
    ],
    "comment": "Two-stage search only advanced the top24 coarse body configurations plus the root candidate. This is sampled exploration, not global optimization; 37 body configurations also received depth-frontier sweeps.",
    "source": "hardware/otterchip_model_e/optimization/scripts/search.cjs:15"
  },
  "fixed_choices": [
    {
      "choice": "Continuous fixed-body integrated desktop architecture with keyboard over the music bay and removable palm cover",
      "why_it_matters": "Stacking forces a higher typing deck and bridge/finger clearance constraints; separate or interchanged typing/music modules were not searched."
    },
    {
      "choice": "355 mm width; same compact typing donor/GK64X-DK61/DSA geometry",
      "values": {
        "typing_below_deck_mm": 16.6,
        "typing_above_deck_mm": 10.8,
        "typing_bed_depth_mm": 102.6
      },
      "why_it_matters": "The key geometry, row spacing, split/splay and low-profile alternatives were not optimization variables."
    },
    {
      "choice": "Photo-derived LPK25 uncased music donor geometry",
      "values": {
        "reserve_mm": 29,
        "travel_allowance_mm": 8,
        "half_bed_width_mm": 146.5
      },
      "why_it_matters": "Donor thickness and underlap set deck thickness and usable black-key length."
    },
    {
      "choice": "10.5-inch AMOLED size/aspect",
      "values": {
        "active_mm": [
          226.56,
          141.6
        ],
        "visible_frame_mm": [
          246.39,
          163.97
        ]
      },
      "why_it_matters": "Alternate screen sizes, portrait layout and larger text were not searched."
    },
    {
      "choice": "Wood music wheels",
      "values": {
        "diameter_mm": 28,
        "width_mm": 4,
        "reveal_mm": 4.5,
        "fore_aft_mm": 20
      },
      "why_it_matters": "Wheel envelope is the binding flat deck-floor term. Relocation or a different wheel/carrier could permit a lower deck."
    },
    {
      "choice": "Cover/carrier thickness3.5 mm; pad width300 mm and depth41 mm; pad corner9 mm, roll6 mm, crown1 mm",
      "why_it_matters": "Pad rise/gap were searched but support depth/shape and a different cover architecture were not."
    },
    {
      "choice": "Rear depth92 mm, rear slope10%, vertical start20%, edge radius4 mm and fluid shell styling",
      "why_it_matters": "Packaging and appearance inherited from M; rear depth affects footprint but not the current posture objective."
    },
    {
      "choice": "Side-mounted headphone and power controls",
      "why_it_matters": "This was a deliberate E change that removed the large front-jack deck-height constraint in M."
    }
  ],
  "fixed_choice_sources": [
    "web/otterchip-optimization-core.js:35",
    "web/otterchip-optimization-core.js:50",
    "web/otterchip-optimization-core.js:56",
    "web/otterchip-model-e.js:3"
  ],
  "physical_constraints": [
    {
      "name": "Typing-bed to black-key gap",
      "rule": "23 mm minimum flat MIDI drop = ceilHalf(16.6 +3 +3); 6 mm robust gap above black tops",
      "selected_actual_mm": 6.4,
      "source": "web/otterchip-optimization-core.js:131"
    },
    {
      "name": "Deck floor",
      "rule": "drop23 + max(donor29,wheel30.5) +floor margin9 =62.5 mm",
      "binding": "wheel envelope",
      "source": "web/otterchip-optimization-core.js:77",
      "qualification": "9 mm includes chosen tolerance/support reserve, not a universal construction minimum. Current CAD physical stack floor is61.2 mm and selected deck has1.3 mm additional margin."
    },
    {
      "name": "Black-key exposure",
      "rule": "At least23 mm of flat black top ahead of the typing bridge in viewer geometry",
      "selected_viewer_mm": 26.1,
      "selected_CAD_mm": 25.05,
      "source": "web/otterchip-optimization-core.js:377",
      "qualification": "The CAD lip projects about1.05 mm farther forward than the simplified viewer edge. Fingers cannot pass underneath the bridge; the gap is smaller than fingertip thickness."
    },
    {
      "name": "Bridge-to-hand clearance",
      "rule": "At least3 mm for tested fingertip, knuckle, palm and wrist points; separate black-key contact checks at5/10 mm behind the top front",
      "source": "web/otterchip-optimization-core.js:344"
    },
    {
      "name": "Sightline",
      "rule": "Eye to active-screen bottom clears the rear typing row",
      "source": "web/otterchip-optimization-core.js:391"
    },
    {
      "name": "Shell, cushion and screen envelope",
      "rule": "Width at least355 mm; pad must fit available fore/aft deck; real front-wall thickness; screen lower edge clears the deck by the shell blend requirement",
      "source": "web/otterchip-optimization-core.js:135"
    },
    {
      "name": "Human feasibility",
      "rule": "No reach miss>5 mm, no arm penetration>1 mm, no knee contact/held-back-by-knees, no dangling feet in evaluated scenarios",
      "source": "web/otterchip-optimization-core.js:290"
    }
  ],
  "objective_and_furniture_assumptions": {
    "ages": "3 through12 equally weighted; 13\u201318 only contextual",
    "activities": "70% typing,30% music",
    "categories": "25% each view,elbow,wrist,reach; view subdivides30% gaze,20% head tilt,25% incidence,25% distance",
    "aggregate": "50% nominal mean +25% short/tall sensitivity mean +25% worst nominal age; any hard failure disqualifies acceptance",
    "human_model": "CDC sex-median stature midpoint with age-interpolated proportional estimates; \u00b18% scaled stature preserves segment ratios and is not a percentile model",
    "furniture": "Automatic adjustment separately at each age AND activity. Seat=popliteal+shoe; table=max(neutral elbow target,knee clearance);26 mm tabletop;20 mm front edge gap; back upright; reach offset0; feet supported.",
    "source": "web/otterchip-optimization-core.js:272",
    "implication": "The loss assumes furniture can change when switching typing/music. It does not establish that one unchanged chair/table configuration is optimal for both activities.",
    "distance_issue": "Zero soft distance penalty from the modeled Harmon distance to1000 mm. The objective lacks text angular size/resolution/visual acuity. A deeper screen can improve the score by narrowing the gaze-angle spread without penalizing reduced readability on a10.5-inch panel.",
    "scope_limits": "Static posture only; dynamic key-playing, forearm pronation, wrist deviation, elbow abduction, prolonged exposure and personal comfort are not validated."
  },
  "recommended_X_scope": [
    "Remove the compactness veto and expand setback beyond250 mm; vary height and tilt broadly until they bracket a stable optimum rather than ending on a numerical bound.",
    "Recheck the same fixed-body/no-moving-parts premise as a stated retained user preference. An architecture search with separated or interchangeable input layers is broader than a larger E shell; do not call a fixed donor architecture unconstrained.",
    "Vary deck slope on both sides of zero only after implementing correct donor/cavity/cover geometry. The E physical gate currently rejects negative slopes for implementation reasons, not a demonstrated ergonomic reason.",
    "Let pad depth/rise/gap, input-underlap and music drop vary; preserve true measured component and finger-travel clearances instead of preserving arbitrary legacy slider minima.",
    "Investigate wheel relocation/alternative wheel mechanism and low-profile typing assembly, which could reduce the binding typing-deck floor; do not simply remove donor/support reserve.",
    "Evaluate alternative screen sizes or require text/UI scaling consistent with the longer viewing distance. Report raw eye distance and screen angular size alongside existing loss.",
    "Use the unchanged E objective for any direct percentage comparison. If the objective or furniture policy is improved, re-evaluate both E and X under the new policy and name it explicitly.",
    "Check one fixed furniture setting per child across typing and music, plus the existing per-activity auto baseline.",
    "Evaluate nominal and scaled bodies, all ages3\u201312 and both activities; report worst cases and black-key finger clearance. Repeat rounded-dimension \u00b11/2 mm sensitivity because solver hip-grid discontinuities produce non-smooth scores.",
    "Validate screen enclosure, display/controller/cable envelopes, structural service paths, key motion, support surfaces and assembled footprint against the actual viewer/CAD; classify X as a buildable concept until donor measurements and physical gates close."
  ],
  "invalid_claims_to_avoid": [
    "E screen tilt was fixed during optimization (false).",
    "The best screen height was limited by maximum300 mm (false; best225 and selected245 are interior).",
    "E was the unconstrained numerical optimum (false; compactness was deliberately preferred over best sampled score).",
    "A38% lower heuristic loss means38% more ergonomic (unsupported).",
    "The selected E is better for music at every age (false; nominal ages3\u20137 had higher music loss than M despite better aggregate).",
    "The donor-only thickness fixes the62.5 mm deck floor (incomplete; music-wheel envelope binds).",
    "The current STLs establish physical donor fit or child sit/lean strength (false; release-status retains physical gates)."
  ],
  "production_source": "hardware/otterchip_model_e/manufacturing/release-status.json"
}
